So this review is going to be a little bit different than my other reviews being that I’ve previously read Sloppy Firsts when I was an eleventh grader in high school. That’s right! I actually read this YA book as a YA! (except the Jessica Darling series is actually published as an adult series proving that YA and adult books can be arbitrarily categorized by the publishers. See also: The Book Thief by Markus Zusak).
So here’s the low down of the book!

“My parents suck ass. Banning me from the phone and restricting my computer privileges are the most tyrannical parental gestures I can think of. Don’t they realize that Hope’s the only one who keeps me sane? . . . I don’t see how things could get any worse.”
When her best friend, Hope Weaver, moves away from Pineville, New Jersey, hyperobservant sixteen-year-old Jessica Darling is devastated. A fish out of water at school and a stranger at home, Jessica feels more lost than ever now that the only person with whom she could really communicate has gone. How is she supposed to deal with the boy- and shopping-crazy girls at school, her dad’s obsession with her track meets, her mother salivating over big sister Bethany’s lavish wedding, and her nonexistent love life? (Poached from Goodreads)
What I can remember from High School Mallory:
I remember not completely liking the book but still being addicted to it and wanting to read more of the series. It was a strange place for me as a book nerd because I usually felt strongly about the books I was reading. I either loved them or I hated them. So reading Sloppy Firsts was a new experience of not really understanding what was irking me about the story but then also wanting to continue to read more of Jessica’s story.
I am completely blaming my lack of ability to pinpoint my emotions to the way I was taught to “critically” read literature in high school. Really I was just taught reading comprehension which was pretty lost on me since I had a high school reading level in, like, sixth grade. NERD ALERT! but yeah, all those extra years of filling in worksheets about what had exactly happened in the story was just boring repetition for me. Yeah, I know what happened because I READ THE BOOK. Jeezy Creez y’all. We need to start asking better questions about literature in high school! Especially since I was in AP English for Junior and Senior year and still NO ONE TAUGHT ME ANYTHING ABOUT CRITICAL READING! Thank you, Jesus, for college. (There’s a point to this rant promise. We just haven’t gotten to it yet)
My Reactions from Now:
My sister has read the entire Jessica Darling series and loves it. I’m the reason she started the series but I stopped somewhere between Charmed Thirds and Fourth Comings (you see what McCafferty is doing with the titles y’all? Do you see it?). Anyways, I’ve always wanted to go back and reread the first two books and then finish the series so that I can be in love with Marcus Flutie along with everyone else who’s ever read this series because fictional boyfriends are the only boyfriends I know how to deal with.
So Sloppy Firsts, I now completely understand why I didn’t like you in high school and yet still was addicted. First off, the writing is fantasballs. Jessica’s voice is just so goddamn funny and sarcastic. Second, it writes about depression in a way that I think not a lot of books talk about. Like Jessica never gets put on anti-depressants and, in fact, no one ever really acknowledges that Jessica is depressed because it’s not clinical or anything. I think depression has this big heavy cloud of “Oh my god DEPRESSION! So big and dark and scary. Take Pills to get rid of it! Take ALL THE PILLS!” but the truth is depression isn’t really like that. Not in most cases and not in Jessica’s case and it’s a breath of fresh air to see it portrayed as such.
So to the point to why I didn’t like it in high school and yet sort of did. Jessica is a whiny, self-centered biznatch. She really is. But guess what, so was I and good God, I did not want to read about someone who was that self-centered and horrible and reminded me of myself. Jessica is a perfect asshole of teenage emotions and selfishness and now that I am no longer a teenager, I can love her for that because I know that she will (hopefully) grow out of it as the books continue like the rest of us do (HOPEFULLY). (the series follow Jessica through the end of college..I think? The last one might be a few years after she graduates from college… can’t remember) But as a teen I didn’t understand that you can not like a character but like the story and the writing. Also that the character may grow as the story goes along, that was not something I think I was aware of either.
BONUS POINTS!
The books start around the year 2000 and Jessica almost immediately talks about Y2K and the Real World (which I hope isn’t as a big of a thing now as it was back then when it still tried to hold onto some dignity.) In Second Helpings, she talks about September 11th happening and it really brings you back to a time and place and feeling that you also felt when it was happening. (except when teens today read about it. They are probably like Y2what? Kids Today! Crazy Whippersnappers!)
I can’t wait to finish this series and find out what happens to Jessica and Marcus.